Recurrence or New Primary?

Ask the Experts on . . . Second Breast Cancer: Local Recurrence or New Primary?

Question How can one determine whether a second breast cancer is a local recurrence or a new primary tumor? Dava F. Gerard, MD, FACS, MS, MPH

Response from Joseph A. Sparano, MD, 08/24/00 Differentiation between a recurrence or a new primary is dependent on the involved breast (ipsilateral vs contralateral), and for ipsilateral lesions depends on the disease-free interval, the location of the lesion relative to the original primary, and the histologic and biological features of the tumor. Most contralateral lesions represent a second primary tumor. Metastasis to the contralateral breast can occur, however, and is often associated with other distant metastases or regional cutaneous, lymphocutaneous, or nodal metastases.

However, most ipsilateral tumors represent recurrences rather than second primaries. In general, ipsilateral recurrences occurring in patients who have had lumpectomy are associated with a more favorable prognosis than local-regional recurrence after mastectomy.

Features associated with a greater likelihood of being a second primary tumor include a long disease-free interval (> 5 years), recurrence in a different segment of the breast from the original primary, and differing clinical or biological characteristics. A careful review of the histologic features with a pathologist is an important component of the evaluation. Other biological features (eg, estrogen/progesterone receptor evaluation, HER2/neu overexpression) may also be useful -- concordance suggests a recurrence, whereas discordance suggests a second primary.

Treatment may consist of mastectomy or reexcision and radiation and will be dependent more on clinical considerations rather than whether the tumor is a recurrence or a second primary.

Suggested Reading Recht A, Hayes DF, Everlein TJ, Sadowsky NL. Local-regional recurrence after mastectomy or breast conserving therapy. In: Harris JR, Lippman ME, Morrow M, Hellman S, eds. Diseases of the Breast. Philadelphia, Pa: Lippincott-Raven; 1996:649-668.


Bca in Surgical Scars

J Surg Oncol, 1976

Reducing the Risk of Locally Recurrent Breast Cancer

MEDSCAPE 12/31/01


Remember we are NOT Doctors and have NO medical training.

This site is like an Encyclopedia - there are many pages, many links on many topics.

Support our work with any size DONATION - see left side of any page - for how to donate. You can help raise awareness of CAM.